Workplace health, safety, risk and emergency training · In person and onlinePartner program1800 231 173
Orana Skills Centre
Home / Documents & Templates / CCV packs / Tailings and Water Storage Failure
Documents & Templates

Tailings and Water Storage Failure Critical Control Verification Pack

Critical control verification (CCV) checklists for tailings and water storage failure: one four-page CCV form for each of the 9 critical controls that stop the unwanted event, uncontrolled release from a tailings storage facility or water storage dam, or limit the harm when it happens, with the bowtie, a verification schedule and a guide.

  • HazardTailings or water held behind a storage embankment
  • Unwanted eventUncontrolled release from a tailings storage facility or water storage dam
  • Critical controls9: 6 preventing, 1 preventing and mitigating, 2 mitigating
  • FormsOne four-page CCV form per control, the bowtie, a CCV schedule and a guide
  • Task or hazardManaging critical risks
  • JurisdictionNational: check licences and notifications with your regulator
  • FormatsWord and Excel, editable, with PDF copies
  • Version1.0 · 5.5 MB ZIP

What is this pack?

The Tailings and Water Storage Failure Critical Control Verification Pack is a set of editable critical control verification (CCV) checklists for tailings dam and water storage risks, for WHS advisers, managers, supervisors and control owners. It covers 9 critical controls (6 preventing, 1 preventing and mitigating, 2 mitigating) for the unwanted event: uncontrolled release from a tailings storage facility or water storage dam. It includes 9 four-page CCV forms in Word and PDF, one for each critical control; the Tailings and Water Storage Failure Bowtie on one page; the CCV schedule in Word, PDF and Excel; and the guide How to Use These CCVs. It draws on the model Code of Practice How to manage work health and safety risks, cited by title. It supports verification; it is not legal advice.

The 9 critical controls

  1. CCV-01 Every raise and change designed and approved by the engineer of record (preventing)
  2. CCV-02 Embankment built to the design under construction quality control (preventing)
  3. CCV-03 Freeboard and the water balance kept within limits (preventing)
  4. CCV-04 Decant and spillway kept clear and working to design capacity (preventing)
  5. CCV-05 Piezometer, survey and seepage monitoring with trigger levels acted on (preventing and mitigating)
  6. CCV-06 Routine surveillance inspections by trained operators (preventing)
  7. CCV-07 Engineer inspections and periodic dam safety reviews done and acted on (preventing)
  8. CCV-08 Emergency action plan with downstream warning and evacuation (mitigating)
  9. CCV-09 People kept out of the flow path and exclusion zones (mitigating)

About this pack

Most workplaces have controls for tailings and water storage failure: engineer-approved raises, freeboard kept, decant and spillway capacity, piezometers and survey monitoring, inspections and an emergency action plan. The question is whether they are working today. A critical control verification (CCV) is the proof: a planned check, in the field, that a control that matters most is in place, in good condition, working as designed, used properly and not bypassed.

This pack gives you one CCV form for each of 9 critical controls (6 preventing, 1 preventing and mitigating, 2 mitigating). Each form shows where the control sits on the bowtie, what it must achieve, how it fails, and a checklist grouped by those five checks and then the records. The last page has prompts for talking to the people who use the control.

Every item is Pass or Fail; Non-conformance is kept for administrative items such as records and training dates, and its box is greyed out on the rest. A Fail stops the work that relies on the control and is escalated as a high potential incident. The download holds 9 four-page CCV forms in Word and PDF, one for each critical control; the Tailings and Water Storage Failure Bowtie on one page; the CCV schedule in Word, PDF and Excel; and the guide How to Use These CCVs.

Where it applies: Tailings storage facilities and water storage dams at mines, quarries and processing plants, including process water ponds, return water dams and sediment and stormwater dams large enough to cause harm if they fail. In Australia, mining has its own work health and safety laws: each state and territory has laws or regulations for mines and quarries, and your site's principal hazard management plans and trigger action response plans come first. The pack gives no design values: every limit is a placeholder for your site's own design criteria and standards.

Where it applies: Tailings storage facilities and water storage dams at mines, quarries and processing plants, including process water ponds, return water dams and sediment and stormwater dams large enough to cause harm if they fail. Your site's dam safety management system, operations manual, principal hazard management plan and trigger action response plans come first: use these forms to verify the controls they set.

What it helps you do

  • Prove, not assume, that the 9 critical controls for tailings and water storage failure are in place and working
  • Score each control the same way every time: Pass, Fail, or Non-conformance for administrative items only
  • Act at once on a Fail, and close every Non-conformance with an owner and a date
  • Hear from the people who use each control where it is skipped or hard to use
  • Report CCV results as a leading indicator, alongside incident data

Each checklist is grouped by

  • It exists: it is there, at this place, for this work, today
  • It is in place and in good condition
  • It functions as designed
  • It is being used properly
  • It is not being bypassed or failing silently
  • Records and administration
Goes with this pack 1 related product

Save with the library

The Critical Control Verification Library holds all 17 CCV packs for $999 incl. GST, $1,534 less than buying them separately$908.18 AUD (GST-free outside Australia), $1,394.55 less than buying them separately.

The critical controls

Each has its own four-page CCV form. Preventing controls sit on the threat lines of the bowtie and stop the unwanted event; mitigating controls sit on the consequence lines and limit the harm. A control on both sides is one control, verified for both roles.

CCVCritical controlTypeSits onChecklist items
CCV-01Every raise and change designed and approved by the engineer of record
Make sure the facility, every raise and every change to its operation or construction is designed by competent engineers, approved by the engineer of record before work starts, and managed through the dam safety management system.
PreventingT110 (2 administrative)
CCV-02Embankment built to the design under construction quality control
Build every raise and repair to the design, with construction quality control the design sets: the right materials, placed and compacted in the right lifts and moisture, the foundation prepared, drains and filters installed, and tested and recorded before the next layer goes on.
PreventingT510 (2 administrative)
CCV-03Freeboard and the water balance kept within limits
Keep the water level at or below the level that leaves [Freeboard requirements], with storm storage available, by managing the water balance: inflows, pumping out and decant return, and acting before the pond reaches the limit.
PreventingT210 (2 administrative)
CCV-04Decant and spillway kept clear and working to design capacity
Keep the decant system and the spillway able to pass the flows in [Spillway and decant design]: clear of blockages, debris and tailings, structurally sound, and not modified or closed off.
PreventingT310 (2 administrative)
CCV-05Piezometer, survey and seepage monitoring with trigger levels acted on
Monitor pore pressures, embankment movement and seepage with the piezometers, survey points and seepage measures the design sets, compare readings with [Monitoring trigger levels], and act on every trigger: investigate and fix the cause (preventing), and warn and clear people from the flow path at the emergency levels (mitigating).
Preventing and mitigatingT4 (preventing); C1 (mitigating)10 (2 administrative)
CCV-06Routine surveillance inspections by trained operators
Look at the whole facility at the interval [Inspection schedule] sets, and after heavy rain, an earthquake or a trigger exceedance, for cracks, slumps, seepage, wet areas, erosion, sinkholes and changes in the pond, and report anything unusual at once.
PreventingT4, T610 (2 administrative)
CCV-07Engineer inspections and periodic dam safety reviews done and acted on
Have the facility inspected by the engineer of record at the interval [Inspection schedule] sets, and reviewed by an independent dam safety review at the interval the dam safety management system or regulator sets, and close out their recommendations.
PreventingT1, T69 (2 administrative)
CCV-08Emergency action plan with downstream warning and evacuation
If the facility starts to fail, or an emergency trigger is reached, carry out the emergency action plan: warn everyone in [Inundation area] on site and downstream, evacuate them to high ground, and alert emergency services and the authorities.
MitigatingC1, C29 (2 administrative)
CCV-09People kept out of the flow path and exclusion zones
Limit who is in harm's way if the facility fails: keep occupied buildings, camps and regular work areas out of [Inundation area] where practicable, control access to exclusion zones on and below the embankment, and keep people off tailings beaches and out of ponds.
MitigatingC19 (2 administrative)

Threats

  • T1 Embankment designed, raised or changed without competent engineering
  • T2 Water rises into the freeboard: rain, inflows or a poor water balance
  • T3 Decant or spillway blocked, undersized or not working, so the dam overtops
  • T4 Seepage, piping, erosion or rising pore pressure weakens the embankment
  • T5 Embankment not built to the design: materials, compaction or placement
  • T6 Deterioration or warning signs not seen or not acted on

Consequences

  • C1 People on site or downstream drowned or buried by the flow
  • C2 Roads, infrastructure and communities downstream damaged or cut off
  • C3 Land, waterways and water supplies contaminated

Supporting controls, shown dashed on the bowtie with no CCV form: Seepage collection and spill containment (on C3).

How each form is scored

The same rules in every pack. The worst item decides the overall result.

MarkWhen
PassYou saw it in place and working, today. A Pass is something you saw, not something you remembered or were told.
FailIt is not in place, or it does not work, or it is bypassed. On an administrative item, use Fail only when what you found means the control itself is not there (for example, nobody on the shift is authorised to operate).
Non-conformance (NC)Administrative items only. The control is in place and working, but a supporting element is missing, late or incomplete: a record, a training date, a review date. Fix it as an action.

Non-conformance is offered only on administrative items: records, training currency, plan and review dates, things that would not on their own cause the unwanted event straight away. Every other item checks that the control is physically there and working, so it is Pass or Fail only: its NC box is greyed out.

Overall resultWhenWhat happens
PASSEvery item PassIn place and effective. Record it in the CCV schedule, and check it against hazard reports, near misses and incidents for this control.
NON-CONFORMANCENo Fail; one or more NCIn place, not fully effective. A temporary control first if needed; an action for each NC, with an owner, closed within 30 days. Tell the supervisor and control owner this shift. A repeat NC is investigated.
FAILAny item FailNOT effective. Stop the work that relies on it, make it safe, and tell the supervisor and the escalation contact now. Report it as a high potential incident. Restart only when the control, or a temporary control the risk owner accepts, is in place and verified again.

Talk to the people

The fourth page of every form: five or six prompts written for that control. Talk to at least two people who use, maintain or supervise this control, on the job and in their own words. Ask open questions and listen: they know where it gets skipped, worked around or is hard to use.

  • Anything that suggests the control is missing, bypassed or not working is checked in the field straight away and scored; confirmed, it is a Fail.
  • Everything else that matters goes in the comments, and each thing to fix becomes an action with an owner and a due date.
  • The people spoken to are told what will happen with what they said, and it is never used against them.

What is included

Delivered as one ZIP download. The files below are editable, and the Word documents also come as PDFs. Each download also includes Read Me First, a Product Overview, the Permitted Use Terms and Version Information (PDF).

FileFormatWhat it is for
How to Use These CCVsWord (.docx)The guide: what a CCV is, how to verify and score, the response to a Fail or Non-conformance, frequency, and how to adapt the pack to your site.
Tailings and Water Storage Failure BowtieWord (.docx)Every threat, consequence and critical control on one landscape page, with its key: which controls prevent, which mitigate, which work on both sides, and the supporting controls.
CCV-01 Every raise and change designed and approved by the engineer of recordWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-02 Embankment built to the design under construction quality controlWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-03 Freeboard and the water balance kept within limitsWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-04 Decant and spillway kept clear and working to design capacityWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-05 Piezometer, survey and seepage monitoring with trigger levels acted onWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-06 Routine surveillance inspections by trained operatorsWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-07 Engineer inspections and periodic dam safety reviews done and acted onWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-08 Emergency action plan with downstream warning and evacuationWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV-09 People kept out of the flow path and exclusion zonesWord (.docx)A four-page field form for one critical control: its bowtie, objective, performance requirements and failure modes, the checklist (Pass, Fail, and Non-conformance on administrative items only), the overall result, actions, talk to the people, and sign-off.
CCV ScheduleWord (.docx)Who verifies each control, how often by exposure, the method and the record: in Word, and as an Excel workbook with suggested frequencies, next due dates and status by formula.
CCV ScheduleExcel (.xlsx)Who verifies each control, how often by exposure, the method and the record: in Word, and as an Excel workbook with suggested frequencies, next due dates and status by formula.

The technical content paraphrases, and cites by title, the mining work health and safety laws and regulations for your state or territory, the dam safety laws and the requirements of the dam safety regulator where they apply to your dam, the guidance on tailings and dam safety from the mines regulator and the national and international dam safety and tailings bodies, the model Code of Practice How to manage work health and safety risks, and your engineer of record's design and advice. Nothing is copied.

Questions about this pack

What is a critical control verification (CCV)?

A planned check, in the field, that one critical control is doing its job: that it exists, is in place and in good condition, functions as designed, is used properly and is not bypassed or failing silently. It is proof, not assumption. It is not a general inspection or audit: it tests one control, in depth, against what it must achieve. A CCV form, or CCV checklist, is the record of that check.

Which critical controls are in the Tailings and Water Storage Failure pack?

9 critical controls (6 preventing, 1 preventing and mitigating, 2 mitigating) for the unwanted event: uncontrolled release from a tailings storage facility or water storage dam. CCV-01 Every raise and change designed and approved by the engineer of record; CCV-02 Embankment built to the design under construction quality control; CCV-03 Freeboard and the water balance kept within limits; CCV-04 Decant and spillway kept clear and working to design capacity; CCV-05 Piezometer, survey and seepage monitoring with trigger levels acted on; CCV-06 Routine surveillance inspections by trained operators; CCV-07 Engineer inspections and periodic dam safety reviews done and acted on; CCV-08 Emergency action plan with downstream warning and evacuation; CCV-09 People kept out of the flow path and exclusion zones. CCV-05 works on both sides of the bowtie: it makes the event less likely and limits the harm if it happens, so the checklist tests both roles.

What is a bowtie, and is it included?

A bowtie is a one-page diagram of a risk: the threats that could cause the unwanted event on the left, the consequences on the right, and the critical controls on each line. The Tailings and Water Storage Failure Bowtie is included in Word and PDF, so you can use it as an editable bowtie template for your site, and each CCV form shows where its control sits on it.

How is a CCV scored?

Pass or Fail on every item. Non-conformance is offered only on administrative items: records, training currency, plan and review dates, things that would not on their own cause the unwanted event straight away. Every other item checks that the control is physically there and working, so it is Pass or Fail only: its NC box is greyed out. Any Fail means the control is not effective: the work that relies on it stops, and it is escalated as a high potential incident. A Non-conformance gets a temporary control if needed and an action closed within 30 days; a repeat is investigated.

What is on the last page of each form?

Talk to the people: five or six prompts written for that control, for the operators, workers and supervisors who use it: what they actually do, when it gets skipped or is hard to use, what has changed, and what they would fix. Anything that suggests the control is missing, bypassed or not working is checked in the field straight away and scored; confirmed, it is a Fail. Everything else that matters goes in the comments, and each thing to fix becomes an action with an owner and a due date.

How often should critical controls be verified?

The CCV schedule (verification schedule) sets how often each critical control is verified, by the exposure where it is used: high (daily exposure, many people or vehicles), medium (weekly, or few people) or low (an occasional task). The guide gives weekly, monthly and quarterly as starting points; each control's own frequencies are set in the schedule. Verify a control in every place it is used, in turn, and more often after a Fail, a near miss or a change, and while an action is open.

Is this pack suitable for my state?

Yes, anywhere in Australia, and outside Australia too. Written to work in any country, with Australian law as the worked example: the documents say to check the law, the regulator and the guidance where you work, and in Australia they work in every state and territory, Victoria included. The model Code of Practice How to manage work health and safety risks and other Australian guidance are cited by title as the example. Some requirements, such as licences, notifying the regulator and registering plant, differ between countries and jurisdictions: check with your regulator. In Australia, your state or territory may have approved the codes with changes, and Victoria has its own Occupational Health and Safety Act and regulations, and WorkSafe Victoria publishes its own guidance. In Australia, mining has its own work health and safety laws: each state and territory has laws or regulations for mines and quarries, and your site's principal hazard management plans and trigger action response plans come first. The pack gives no design values: every limit is a placeholder for your site's own design criteria and standards.

Can we change the forms?

Yes. Every form, the bowtie and the schedule are editable Word and Excel files: add your logo and business name, your site's limits, plant and roles, delete items that do not apply and add your own. The guide says what to adapt, and how to decide whether a new item may offer Non-conformance.

Is it legal advice, or the same as an audit?

No. These forms help your business prove that its critical controls are in place and working. They do not do that on their own: adapt them to your site, plant and people, verify in the field, and act on what you find. The forms are general information, not legal advice. Work health and safety law differs between jurisdictions and changes over time. Check the requirements that apply where you operate.

Is GST included in the price?

Yes, for buyers in Australia: every price in the store includes GST, so $149.00 is the total, including $13.55 GST, and your receipt is a tax invoice showing the GST. Buyers outside Australia don't pay GST: you pay $135.45, the price without the GST, and your receipt shows no GST.

How are the files delivered?

As a ZIP download. Card purchases can be downloaded straight away from the confirmation page and by a link we email you. Download links expire after 14 days for security; you can request a new one at any time.

Can we use it at more than one site?

Yes, across your own organisation. The pack is licensed for internal use by the purchasing organisation. A consultant using it with clients needs separate written permission.

What is your refund policy?

Your rights under the Australian Consumer Law are not affected. See the Refund Policy for how we handle a product that is faulty, not as described, or not what you ordered.

Legal information here is general. It may not be correct in your jurisdiction: please check with your local WHS or OHS regulator.

Ordering for a business or several sites? Request an invoice. Other questions: contact us.

Goes with

The plan that sets up the critical risk program these forms verify. The Critical Control Management training packages.

Critical Risk Management Plan

For: Australian businesses with work that could kill or seriously injure someone, and the officers, managers, supervisors and WHS advisers who manage those risks

A complete, editable critical risk management plan for Australian businesses: find the risks that could kill, map them with bowties, define, own and verify the critical controls, aligned to the model WHS laws and ISO 31000.

What's included
  • The critical risk management plan, a policy, and a roles and accountabilities guide with officers' due diligence
  • A broad-brush workshop guide, an Excel critical risk register that tiers and ranks each risk on the same risk matrix as the WHS plans, and a drawn bowtie template
  • A critical control selection checklist, performance standard template, control owner accountability statement and Excel critical controls register
  • An Excel verification program and schedule, a generic verification form scored Pass, Fail or Non-conformance, an officers' report, a failure response procedure and a dashboard
$349incl. GST$317.27AUD, GST-free outside Australia
Add to CartRequest Invoice

Training: Critical Control Management Practitioner · Critical Control Management Implementation Toolkit